I know, I said I wouldn't be back, and I'm not, but I wanted to reach everybody I could about this issue.  I sent this e-mail to everybody on my address list, and then I thought of all of you.

 

 I read yesterday in the paper about a TV show that is going to begin airing on June 25 on NBC.  I was really upset about the show and I wanted to invite you to join me if you happen to agree with me. 

 

I'm sending this to everyone on my address list, so if you don't remember who I am, Sorry!

 

   Just wanted you to know, as quickly as possible, that I will regretfully end my 45 year long relationship with what has been a fine network if you air a single episode of baby borrowers.  That you have condoned removing children for 72 hours from their primary caregivers is abominable.  Your purported admirable motive blinded you to participating in human slavery and abuse. 
   It is no longer hard for me to believe that no one in your programming department had the wits to consider the effect on these children as a counterbalance to cheap programming. 
   You need to foot the bill for parenting classes for those who rented out their children.  That the adults knew the children were safe is interesting, but the children could not have known that they were themselves safe. 
   How could you do such a thing?

Thank you for sharing this. It was good to hear.

From NBC message board Question from someone. I do think that some of the parents handled the distress of watching their children's angst a bit harshly. A calmer approach probably would have gone over better and not put the teens on the defense immediately. I think it shows that there is a bit of impatience on the parents' part.

Response
It probably does appear that way on television, but unfortunatey they have to condense 72 hours x 5 households into 1 one hour episode. So it looks like we just immediately fly off the handle, and that isn't the case. In all actuality we were extremly patient and understanding of the teens' learning curves. I know that in my case, the incident that prompted me to go over to speak to Sean and Kelsey was over a period of SEVERAL hours. When I finally went over, I was in pajamas and it was in the early hours of the morning, but they had started trying to get her to sleep in the early evening.

Wow I haven't seen this show yet. I wanted to see what it was about but forgot all about it. I had no idea all of this was going on because of the show.

Been out of the loop for a while since we've been away. Haven't seen the show, although I'm still curious about it. Also haven't had time to read all the posts here since there's so many. Wld never put my children through anything like this b/c I think the whole idea is unnecessary and definitely there to bring in $$ and ratings to NBC. I've said all this before. Was wondering, though, about the timeframe these children are separated from their parents. While on vacation I did some thinking about this. I used to work as a nanny for 2 different families, as well as babysat for many others. I'm also a mother of 2 young children. As a nanny, there was a transition period for both me and the children, as it took some time to get used to one another. I was a total stranger to these children as they were strangers to me. In each case, both parents worked long hrs. I was left w/ the kids from the moment they woke up in the morning, to the time they went to bed at night. Long hrs to say the least, and the kids barely saw their parents. In a way I felt like a second mom to them. I did everything for them. I feel that the kids got as attached to me, as I did to them. There was even a time when the parents took a trip, leaving me w/ the kids for an entire wkend! By that time I knew them quite well, but it was still a bit unusual, now that I look back on it. In the case of both families, the parents chose to work, it was not a necessity. They were well off. I had fun w/ the kids and would take them here, there and everywhere. Not sure I'd allow just anyone to do that w/ my own children, but the parents trusted me. I still keep in touch w/ the one family who lives not too far from me, and I see the boys from time to time. Their grown now, and their doing well. They're happy, well adjusted young men who are involved in sports and are doing well in school. We have a good relationship, and I'm happy I have the opportunity to stay in touch w/ them. They've taught me a lot about what it's like to be a mom, and overall, I learned a lot from my experience w/ them, as well as w/ the other children I cared for. So here's another perspective from my experience as a nanny, which in my view was a good one. Does anyone have any comments on this, seeing it from my point of view? I was w/ these children for several yrs, and initially, I was the stranger. In Baby Borrowers (since I don't know the details of the show), how long are these teens expected to care for these children at one time? Do you think that length of time has a greater impact on these children, or does it not make a difference? In my experience, it was a positive one. Yes, the parents did come home at the end of the day, after the kids were in bed, and they saw their children first thing in the morning, but only briefly. Do you think this made all the difference? Just curious what everyone's thoughts are on this persective.

I think the show is helping the teenagers out tremendesly. They know they are not ready to have kids now. Does anyone agree with me?...This show is showing all kids that its not all fun and games. If they didn't come on the show you know in a heartbeat they would get pregnant.I can assure you after they are done with the show that they are going to wait until they are mature and are older to have kids.

I don't know, Debbiedoo. Do you know how many teens are sexually active and irresponsible about it? They have that "it will never happen to me" attitude. I agree that the show can be beneficial to some and bring light to the reality of parenthood, but will it really stop teens from having sex? In my opinion, it's not a foolproof solution. Sometimes it takes making a mistake to learn a lesson. I think what Gail is trying to say is that these teens have other means of birth control and learning lessons, rather than participating in an experimental show that can have long-term affects on the children. These children have no say in the matter. The parents and the teens make the decisions, not the children. Is it worth airing a show like this to "see what happens" when innocent children's lives are at stake? I don't know. And is there a real lesson to learn here, or is this really about $$ and ratings. Like w/ abortion, the parents are the ones making the decisions. However, what say do these babies have in the matter? NONE! I think that's what Gail's trying to say here. I personally wldn't put my kids through an experiment such as this on Baby Borrowers, but if it takes a show like this for parents and teens to learn life lessons, that's their doing, and they have to face the consequences in the end. Will there be consequences down the road? Who knows. But why take the risk.

hi, i live in england and the baby borrowers has been done 3 times over here. the first time i watched and it was horrible. one set of the teens just argued all of the time and then on the 3rd day i think it was, the teenage boy left the baby on the sofa in a car seat and the parents removed him. he was aroud 6 months old i think. i remember thinking i could never leave Alyssa with people i dont know and whome she has never met for a week especially teenagers like the ones the show chose. i must admit that a couple of the teens wee great at looking after the babies but i still wouldnt do it. the last baby borrowers was from birth to old age. they had the teens look after a baby then a toddler, a 6 year old, a teenager and then an elderly person. the teens seemed to cope better with the elderly but i remember one of the teens making fun of an old man in a nappy and thinking....why the hell are the making this show. i can see whay some people may find it a good idea to give teens the responsibility so that they think aboout not having babies really early but thats what those robot doll things are for. this is a stage too far.

I am a teen parent myself and many of my friends think that I have it easy. Well newsflash its not. I was glad to see the show was going to be on and I hope that it showed all the teens that it isn't easy. I myself had a very close friend watch my child for only a couple of hours to give her a taste as to how easy my LIFE isn't. When I got home later that day she told me she had taken for granted what I was doing and that she was extremely proud of me. I think it was a big eye opener for her and I personally every teen should have to deal with something like that to learn its not all easy...