Out of these, which do you like the most?  Thanks for your help: ) Katie Alice Macy Beth Sarah Elizabeth Tara Julie Maria  
Hey blackngold,   I like Sarah Elizabeth best, one of my daughter's best friends is named Sarah Elizabeth and she is just the sweetest girl.  Also, I have never known a Sarah that wasn't a great girl!    Marti   http://www.familyeducation.com/home/
I like Katie Alice. My granddaughter is called Katie-Louise
I really like Sarah Elizabeth or Katie Alice.  Maybe even Kate Alice would be good.  Best of luck!
I like Sarah Elizabeth...it has a regal quality to it that is just right for a little lady.  For short you can call the child Sadie...casual and precocious...the best of both worlds for a special little girl.
Definitely Katie Alice, very Victorian and grand.
I like Sarah Elizabeth better! Sounds sweet.
Those are all really pretty, feminine names.  My little girl's name is Macy Kathryn, so I love Macy.  You can't go wrong with any of your choices, but I would use Katherine or some variation instead of Katie.  That way you have a sweet nn and a more formal option for when she grows up.
I think Tara is a nice name. My sister's dauther is named that.
As a combo I think that Sarah Elizabeth is the best from your list. I think that Katherine Alice is lovely nn Kate. Tara said the Aussie way is nice, it is a bit Gone with the Wind, a combo for this may be Tara Scarlett Julie Maria is not so good Julie Maree would be better. I prefer Juliette, and Marielle as the middle name.  Juliette Marielle. Sorry Macy and Beth are not my style.
I like Sarah Elizabeth the best. They sound very nice together. My cousin has a little girl named Sarah and I have a neice by the same name. They are both beautiful girls. Good luck to you.